Stain or Paint? What is the best option for your front door

Henry Warner • October 17, 2017

The first aspect of your home people notice is the front door. It can boost curb appeal and increase your home’s value. For these reasons, choosing the better finish, stain or paint, is essential. There are several factors to consider when dealing with a fiberglass front door and persuasive reasons to use either of these finishing methods.

When Paint is Better for Fiberglass Front Doors

If you are looking for a front door with a solid flat finish, painting is the better method for finishing. Many models of fiberglass doors are built with smooth exteriors making a painted finish the better option. Doors such as these, are created to be painted; with staining, not being an effective finish.

Many builders have a belief that fiberglass door surfaces become more durable when painted and not stained. In many instances, this is true, however, with so many variables it is difficult to accurately make an overall comparison. The durability of a door’s finished surface varies greatly on materials used, in which way the finish was placed on the door, the weather it is exposed to, and attention given to the door for required maintenance. Of most importance, is the strength and quantity of sunlight in which the door is subjected to. Fiberglass front doors exposed to strong sunlight should be finished with paint, not stain.

When Stain is a Better Finish for Fiberglass Front Doors

Textured front fiberglass doors look better when stained, however, either finish can be used. If your preference is a look of wood rather than fiberglass, staining can be used to accomplish this. This finishing method allows homeowners to appreciate the easy maintenance that is known with fiberglass as well as the look of an attractive wood grain.

If many wood details are included in the exterior of your home, textured fiberglass with an appearance of wood for a front door is a great choice. Exterior wood accents can be matched successfully when with this choice of finish. A fiberglass surface with a stained finish can match several different kinds of wood such as cedar, oak, walnut, cherry, and mahogany.

If you are considering a makeover for your existing fiberglass front door or installing a new one, this information can help you decide if stain or paint is the better finish for your needs. For more details, contact Jeff of All Trades today!


Garage Organization Hacks
By Faseeh Blackloup September 26, 2025
Shelving, overhead racks, pegboards, and Jeff’s custom garage systems turn chaos into square-foot gold. Boost storage and home value now.
Handyman vs Big Box NJ
By Faseeh Blackloup September 21, 2025
Discover how Jeff’s local handyperson service outshines big-box store installs in quality, warranty, and accountability.
Kitchen Cabinet Refacing vs. Replacement
By Faseeh Blackloup September 17, 2025
Compare costs, timelines & eco-impact of cabinet refacing vs. complete replacement in NJ. Real numbers, Jeff’s master carpentry tips & FAQs inside.
Small Bathroom Tile NJ
By Faseeh Blackloup September 12, 2025
Diagonal, chevron & large-format tile tricks that visually enlarge tight New Jersey baths—plus grout-color hacks and easy formulas to cut waste.
Kitchen Recessed Lighting NJ
By Faseeh Blackloup September 7, 2025
Learn the spacing formulas, lumen targets, and can-light types that make any New Jersey kitchen shine—whether your ceiling is 8 ft or 12 ft high.
Landscape Lighting Somerset NJ
By Faseeh Blackloup September 1, 2025
Discover Bob Vila-style landscape lighting ideas, costs, and Jeff’s 24-hour install service for Somerset County, NJ, homeowners. Peace of mind starts here.
Waterproofing Basement Walls
By Faseeh Blackloup August 27, 2025
Learn why New Jersey basements leak, the best interior and exterior waterproofing methods, and more.
Driveway Sealing Myths & Facts
By Faseeh Blackloup August 22, 2025
Stop wasting money on driveway sealing myths. Discover the facts about sealant types, optimal timing, DIY vs. professional costs, and more.
Deck Repair Warning Signs
By Faseeh Blackloup August 17, 2025
Spot rot, loose joists, and other post-winter deck dangers early. Learn the professional repair timeline for Somerset County, NJ.
Gutter Cleaning Schedule
By Faseeh Blackloup August 12, 2025
Learn the best seasons, ladders, and pro tools for safe gutter cleaning on two- and three-story New Jersey homes.